• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • FAQ
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Raymond-nh

Make Your Ideally Home

  • Home
  • Electric Smoker
    • Comprehensive Buying Guide
    • Top 5 Masterbuilt 40 Smoker Reviews
    • Best Portable Smokers
    • Gas vs Electric Smoker
    • Best Meats to Smoke in Electric Smoker
  • Gas Grill
    • 10 Best High End Gas Grills
    • Best Gas Grills Under $500
    • P3 SXN Broilmaster Grill Reviews in 2019
    • 4 Best Gas Grill with Rotisserie in 2019
    • Gas vs Electric Smoker – Which One Should You Choose?
    • Weber Spirit vs Genesis : Ultimate Battle 2019 [Updated]
    • 5 Best Built in Grills That Will Make Your Paradise
  • Charcoal Grill
    • 10 Best Charcoal Smoker 2019
    • 5 Best Portable Charcoal Grill That Make Grill ‘n Go 2019
    • How to Use Wood Pellets in Charcoal Grill
    • Weber 731001 Smokey Mountain Cooker 22-inch
    • Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS1382VCS-D
    • The Magic of Ceramic Briquettes in Charcoal Grill
  • Pellet Grill
    • Best Pellet Smoker 2019
    • Pit Boss vs Traeger Pellet Grill
    • Traeger Renegade Elite vs Pro Series
    • Traeger Renegade Pro Pellet Grill Review
    • Camp Chef PG24 Pellet Grill Review
    • Pit Boss 700s Reviews
    • Z Grills Master 700D Review
    • Traeger Renegade Elite Review
    • Traeger Renegade Pro Review
    • Camp Chef Woodwind SG Review
  • Accessories
    • 10 Best Wood Chips for Masterbuilt
    • 5 Best Meat Thermometer for Smoker in 2019
    • Weber Igrill 3 Thermometer
  • Blog
    • How to Smoke Cheese on a Pellet Grill
    • How to Smoke Ribs on a Pellet Grill
    • How to Cook Steak on Pellet Grill
    • How To Smoke a Turkey On a Pellet Grill
    • How To Smoke a Brisket On a Pellet Grill
    • How to Cook Burgers on Pellet Grill
    • How to Cook Bacon on a Pellet Grill
    • How to Clean Your Electric Smoker
    • How to use an Electric Smoker [Pro Tips]
    • How to Use Wood Pellets in Charcoal Grill Made Simple
    • The Magic of Ceramic Briquettes in Charcoal Grill
    • Who Makes Cabelas Pellet Grill
  • Appliance
    • Cooktop
    • Rice Cooker
    • Pressure Cookers
You are here: Home / Why You Should Buy a Grill / Gas Grills / Gas vs Electric Smoker

Gas vs Electric Smoker

Last updated on May 5, 2019 by Raymond

Raymond-nh is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Gas vs Electric Smoker one cannot tell the story of human meat consumption without talking about how we’ve been smoking it since the beginning of time. Perhaps that’s why smoked meat has a powerful allure for humans. It’s because our ancestors were doing it long before we even knew how to string words together.

However, several smoking techniques have emerged since then, with most of the innovation being driven by technology. The most popular implements that we have at our disposal for smoking meat are the gas smoker and the electric smoker.

gas vs electric smoker which one betterBoth of these tools are fairly recent inventions that represent man’s foray into technological innovation. Of course, these implements allow the user to access different smoking techniques and each has different strengths and weaknesses. While the gas smoker might work for certain occasions, it may not work for other situations that are better suited to its electric counterpart, and vice versa.

If you’re thinking of buying either a gas or electric smoker then you’ve come to the right place. We’ve put together a helpful guide that will help you determine which option is best for your needs. We did some research to find out what the main characteristics of each machine are, and then we proceeded to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each option.

Our goal is to help you make an informed buying decision. We know how stressful it can be to end up with a product that’s completely different from what you expected. Unfortunately, this happens all the time and its main cause is a lack of information on the product.

So read on to find out more about

Go to top

Looking for

  • What is an Electric Smoker?
  • What is a Gas Smoker?
  • The Differences of Propane vs Electric Smoker
  • Gas vs Electric Smoker Which is Better

What is an Electric Smoker?

An electric smoker is powered by thermal energy and it comes with an internal heating element that’s designed to yield electric heat. The smoker uses this heat to fire up the wood chips you chuck into it and out comes smoke on the other side.

There are quite a few distinguishing factors that make electric smokers unique from other types of smokers on the market. For one, it has a digital control panel that you won’t find on a gas smoker, and this feature alone makes life so much easier for the user. The control panel is what you use to determine temperature settings and you can use it to customize the smoking process by choosing a particular type of meat.

Switching your electric smoker is as easy as clicking a single button and it will automatically take care of the rest. Of course, you’ll have to set the temperature to your preferred level and choose the type of meat you’d like to smoke but that only takes a few seconds at best.

As the name implies, electric smokers are powered by electric energy, which heats up the internal heating element to produce heat. From there, the smoker can easily operate for five hours on the same wood chips and without constant supervision. Plus, all you need is four wood chip cups that will last for that entire time period.

As with anything, electric smokers have their pros and cons which we’ve detailed below for you to see:

Pros

  • Electric smokers generally offer generous cooking space and allow you to cook different types of food with ease.
  • The digital control panel allows you to “set it and forget it” so you can spend more of your time socializing instead of constantly checking on the meat.
  • It’s really easy to use and switches on at the press of a button.
  • Electric smokers usually feature a modern and sleek design which means they won’t look out of place in a modern kitchen.
  • Features like the integrated thermometer reduce the number of “extras” that you need to buy, and it makes it much more convenient to use compared to gas-powered models.
  • It’s perfect for slow smoking.
  • Since it does most of the tasks on its own, the electric smoker is ideal for anyone that leads a busy lifestyle because it enables you to multitask.
  • They’re safer to use thanks to the integrated insulation, which is a missing feature in most gas smokers.

Cons

  • It’s pricier than its gas counterparts.
  • It’s bulkier and heavier than a gas smoker.
  • The quality of the food smoked by an electric smoker pales in comparison to that of a gas smoker.
  • It takes longer to cook food.
  • You can’t use it without electricity access.
  • It’s not portable.
  • It has a limited temperature range that only goes up to 300 degrees Fahrenheit. A natural gas smoker, on the other hand, can go up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit, allowing you to smoke meat at high temperatures.
Bestseller
Masterbuilt MB20071117 Digital Electric Smoker, 30 inch, Black
Save: $39.69Bestseller
Masterbuilt MB20074719 Bluetooth Digital Electric Smoker, 40 inch, Stainless Steel
Bestseller
Char-Broil 19202101 Deluxe Black Digital Electric Smoker, Large, 725 Square Inch
Go to top

What is a Gas Smoker?

A gas smoker sources heat from natural gas or propane gas. It has an internal heating element that’s responsible for creating the smoke needed for smoking meat. The only difference is that gas smokers are a bit more demanding of your attention and they require quite a bit of oversight.

also see Broilmaster super premium gas grill review

You’ll have to keep an eye on the heat to make sure that the temperature doesn’t lead to over or under cooking. Gas smokers have a wide temperature range that can easily reach 400 degrees Fahrenheit.

The type of wood chips you put into the smoker will play a huge role in the smoker’s temperature and the flavor of your meat. Although there are a lot of benefits to using a gas smoker, it also comes with its own limitations. Read on for the pros and cons of using a gas smoker.

Weber is top brand for gas grill or smoker. therefore you should miss this battle
The battle of Weber genesis vs spirit

Pros

  • You can use your gas smoker anywhere as it doesn’t require any electrical power to work.
  • It’s a cost-effective option compared to an electric smoker.
  • It’s ideal for use on the road because it heats up quickly and speeds up cooking time.
  • It’s easy to use and doesn’t require any technical experience to set up or operate.
  • It’s portable so you can take it with you when boating or camping. It’s also perfect for professional mobile chefs like food truck owners.
  • It has a wide temperature range which gives you more freedom when smoking different types of meat.

Cons

  • It’s time-consuming. You need to be present at all times to regulate the temperature because none of its functions are automatic.
  • It’s an analog piece of machinery that doesn’t have useful features like an integrated food thermometer. This makes it less convenient to work with when compared to an electric smoker.
  • A fair amount of know-how is required if you want to make the most of your gas smoker.
  • It’s smaller in size so there isn’t much cooking space which may limit your catering ability.
  • It’s not insulated and can be hazardous to handle if you’re not familiar with it.
Save: $10.38Bestseller
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smoker, Black
Bestseller
Dyna-Glo DGY784BDP 36" Vertical LP Gas Smoker
Bestseller
PIT BOSS 77435 Vertical Lp Gas Smoker, Red
Go to top

The Differences of Propane vs Electric Smoker

The Differences of Gas vs Electric SmokersNow that you more or less understand what each option has to offer, we’re going to compare the two based on a few key features. We recommend that you consider your needs as you read through this comparison guide as that will help you figure out which option is best for you.

Lastly, we’ll reveal what our preferred option is between the two and why we recommend it specifically.

Ease of Use

Electric smokers are designed for convenience and ease of use, which is something that’s missing with gas smokers. Plus, electric smokers come with great features that make your life easier, such as a LED display, a control panel, internal thermometer and others that allow you to automate the smoking process.

Safety

Electric smokers are designed with safety in mind, as shown by the amount of insulation that they provide. On the other hand, the propane in gas smokers can potentially leak and cause explosions and they’re not insulated so handling them is not easy.

Price

Electric smokers cost significantly more than gas smokers, with prices starting from $200 to $400. On the other hand, you can easily find a good quality gas smoker for just $150.

Quality of Food Smoked

Gas smokers allow you to smoke meat at high temperatures that you cannot achieve with an electric smoker. As a result, some people prefer gas smokers because they provide better flavor overall.

Design and Size

Electric smokers typically offer generous cooking space and feature up to four racks each. The gas smoker has a smaller cooking surface which limits the amount of meat that you can cook in one go.

Go to top

Gas vs Electric Smoker Which is Better

Based on general customer needs and requirements, we’ve come to the conclusion that electric smokers are a better option compared to gas smokers. That’s because electric smokers offer more convenience, and they’re safer and easier to use.

As we’ve noted in this article, gas smokers have their benefits but they’ve fallen behind when it comes to innovation. That’s why we’re willing to put our money on electric smokers and recommend them for pros and beginners alike.

Bestseller related the post

Save: $10.38Bestseller
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36" Propane Smoker, Black
Bestseller
Masterbuilt MB20070210 Analog Electric Smoker with 3 Smoking Racks, 30 inch, Black
Save: $10.04Bestseller
Pellet Smoker Tube, 12'' Stainless Steel BBQ Wood Pellet Tube Smoker for Cold/Hot Smoking, Portable Barbecue Smoke Generator Works with Electric Gas Charcoal Grill or Smokers, Bonus Brush, Hexagon
0/5 (0 Reviews)

Last update on 2021-03-07 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Related Posts:

  • 10 Best Electric Smoker That Will Make Your Life Easy 201910 Best Electric Smoker That Will Make Your Life Easy 2019
  • How to Clean Electric Smoker The Easy WayHow to Clean Electric Smoker The Easy Way
  • How to Use An Electric Smoker That Make You Like a ProHow to Use An Electric Smoker That Make You Like a Pro
  • Best Meats to Smoke in Electric SmokerBest Meats to Smoke in Electric Smoker

I am a passionate food and grill lover, and I like to eat juicy beef ribs. My first grill brand was Traeger cause when I was a noob my Traegie can help me a lot. Anyway, Napoleon is the one I would love and someday I will take it. I hope you enjoy my articles and the advice I give you.

Primary Sidebar

Footer

Contact Us

raymond-nh

Contact us: [email protected]

ABOUT US

We understand that for many, barbecuing is a tradition. Furthermore, it’s a cooking style that requires both science and art to perfect. In other words, it’s not as simple as it may sound and you need all the help you….read more

Follow

GoogleTwitterPinterest

© 2021 · Raymond-nh.com | Privacy Policy · Disclaimer · About Us